Karen invites Bill's ex-wife, Betty, to dinner, which gets Jeff in trouble with all his friends. He's in even more trouble when Betty starts blurting out intimate details of her and Bill's marriage. Meanwhile, Matt and Nettie try to con Justin out of his money by inviting him to join their club.

Jeff and Big Jim are arrested for cutting down a Christmas tree in a state park.

Karen tries to end a long-standing family feud by inviting the rival Raffertys to dinner.