Mikey opens a Kappa Mikey-themed restaurant, which does lousy until Gonard starts preparing dishes for it. A rival restaurant nabs Gonard and hypnotizes him into making dishes for them instead. In the subplot, Lily is caught showing hatred toward babies, so Ozu forces her to take care of a baby for one day to regain LilyMu’s reputation.

At a video rental store on Halloween, Mikey comes across a "creepy, unmarked" DVD, and after watching it, he and his friends are cursed. Their one way to break the curse is to assist a girl named Samoa to find her gobstopper in a haunted house, looking out for clues from the DVD itself.