The boys throw out everything they believe to be baby toys, leaving them with an empty Fanlair.

Fanboy and Chum Chum accidentally cause Kyle to lose a tooth, which means the Wizard Tooth Fairy is coming. But unlike the normal Tooth Fairy, when the Wizard Tooth Fairy comes, he takes all your teeth.

After losing their memories from a wicked brain freeze, Fanboy and Chum Chum must retrace their steps to locate their missing underwear.