Acting on Phoebe's premonitions, the sisters race to stop a mysterious killer from striking again. Meanwhile, Prue finds a truth spell and uses it to find out what Andy's reaction to her being a witch would be.

Prue helps a young witch who has been kidnapped, and renews her own faith in having children. Meanwhile, Phoebe finds out that Leo is hiding an important secret that threatens his relationship with Piper.

After Prue's former crush, Bane, is broken out of jail, he seeks her help for defeating a powerful demon by... kidnapping her. Meanwhile, Phoebe tries to help Piper choose between Dan and Leo by casting a spell, but the results are rather unexpected.

Paige finds herself transported back in time to an era of free love and free magic, where she discovers Grams, a peace-loving hippie, who is on a crusade to rid the world of evil through the magical power of love.