The Charmed Ones have their hands full, when thanks to a bored Magic School student, they must keep Lord Dyson from killing the infamous Lady Godiva before she can travel back in time and complete her famous ride. Meanwhile, Phoebe has reservations about Les being able to properly write an advice column for women.

When Paige encounters Captain Black Jack Cutting, an 18th century pirate in search of the Fountain of Youth, the curse on his life becomes her problem. Meanwhile, Leslie manipulates a contest in order to spend time with Phoebe, Leo fights with the creature that caused him to kill an Elder, and a mysterious federal agent comes to town to investigate the Halliwells.

When a blue moon causes amok at the same time the girls are assigned a new whitelighter, thanks to the Elder's suspicion of Leo, trouble brews. Meanwhile, Agent Brody tells Paige of a powerful new threat, and Phoebe & Leslie confess their true feelings for each other as Leslie prepares to leave.