When the brothers make a bet involving a prank on Jackie, she turns to Katherine but learns that the boys have their own way of handling their issues.

At the Homecoming Huddle, Alex and Jackie run the Walter family cider cart together with help from Cole, who struggles to accept life without football.

On Lucy's birthday, Jackie decides to skip school and attend a lake house party with Cole, where the two play a high-stakes version of Truth or Dare.

As rumors fly about the Walter boys, Alex and Cole's sibling rivalry reaches its breaking point. Later, the family deals with an unsettling emergency.

When Katherine wins an award for her veterinarian work, the family jumps to support her — except Cole, who instead heads down a path of self-destruction.