When 15 Division goes undercover at a club-land bar that's a possible hub for illegal handguns, Chris's erratic behaviour and concern for a specific drug dealer make Dov suspicious. Meanwhile – after learning Duncan has made serious professional allegations against her – Andy decides to help Sam with a missing person's case that takes a dark turn.

As the officers of 15 Division try to hunt down the killer of Brian Gowdy, Andy and Sam go on the road to interview a list of inmates at Millburn Penitentiary. All are known associates of the prime suspect; one person on that list happens to be none other than Jay Swarek, Sam's elusive father.