When Timmy asks his fairies to use their magic to make Chester the “best baseball player” ever, things go from bad, to great, to worse.

Timmy's friends, A.J. and Chester argue and break their friendship. When they each invite him to their respective sleepovers on the same night, to watch a Crash Nebula/Crimson Chin crossover special, this creates a problem for Timmy. How will he join both of them without being discovered? How will he reunite his friends?

It's time for the Father-Son Squirrely Scout competition, but Dad gets called away for work, leaving Timmy without a partner.