Carly is dating a boy named Steven who divides his time between his divorced parents who live in Seattle and Los Angeles. Meanwhile, Tori is also spending time with her new boyfriend who, unbeknownst to her, is the very same boy Carly is seeing. The iCarly gang stumbles upon a photo of Steven and Tori on The Slap. André gets permission to host a party at Kenan Thompson's house with his friends.

After discovering Steven to be a cheater, the iCarly gang take off their disguises and explain the situation to Tori. The two hatch a plan to embarrass him on iCarly.