Lindy is excited about her new gig as the school's food critic until she dines at a family restaurant and the food is terrible. Meanwhile, Jasmine gets a babysitting job and winds up competing with her nine-year-old charge.

Lindy tries to play matchmaker for Garrett and the new girl in school, who seems to be even more socially awkward than Garrett.

When Lindy’s latest foster dog Lucky appears to like Logan more, the twins compete for the dog’s affection. Meanwhile, Jasmine accidentally sells Garrett’s vintage action-figure at a garage sale.