Cameron Seely as Mary
Episodes 22
Red Velvet If You Please
Jeannie asks Jim to run some important errands, including dropping off their daughter's application to a prestigious Catholic girls' school.
Read MoreA Night at the Plaza
Jim organizes a romantic anniversary including a Broadway show and a short hotel stay
Read MoreIn the Name of the Father
Jim and Jeannie agree to dine with Daniel and his father in order to act as buffers; Dave joins the group for a wild night.
Read MoreSuper Great Daddy Day
Jeannie asks Jim to run some important errands, including dropping off their daughter's application to a prestigious Catholic girls' school.
Read MoreGo Shorty, It's Your Birthday
Jim celebrates Dave's birthday instead of Jeannie's, and even though she told him not to give her a gift or celebrate, Jeannie gets upset.
Read MoreMy Friend the Priest
When Jim is finally invited to do "The Tonight Show With Jimmy Fallon," Jeannie invites Father Nicholas along, making Jim more nervous.
Read MoreThe Bible Story
After Jim is photographed holding a Bible, he finds himself at the center of a firestorm.
Read MoreThe Calling
Jim searches for his purpose in life and finds startling answers.
Read MoreNo Good Deed (1)
Jim tries to help his friend Dave who has hit a low point in his career.
Read MoreNo Good Deed (2)
Jim finds out that a huge movie star has taken an interest in him and flies to LA for an exciting project. But will his nerves get the better of him?
Read MoreNo Good Deed (3)
Jim is enlisted to help Dave with a project and things get completely out of control.
Read MoreHe Said She Said
Jim and Jeannie have a huge fight and seek Father Nicholas's counsel only to discover what they are truly in conflict about.
Read MoreMy Brother's Keeper
Jim's brother visits New York and makes a life altering decision. Jim must decide if he should support his brother or follow his heart.
Read MoreJim at the Museum
Jim takes all of his kids to the museum by himself and has an adventure that no one will forget.
Read MoreBosom Buddies
Jeannie heads out of town with the kids and Jim navigates New York City alone for the weekend.
Read MoreThe Mike Gaffigan Show
During a scary storm, Jim consoles his children by telling them a story from his own childhood and in the process learns an important lesson about his past.
Read More