Hope, still feeling guilty for stealing Tess' blind date, sends Alex away after Tess stands him up, then begs him to come back after Tess revels she's met someone else. When Berk convinces Kevin to get in bed with the fake Natalie (a.k.a. the blow-up doll), so that he can "pretend" to catch his "girlfriend" cheating on him, the real Natalie shows up, forcing Berk to tell Lori that he has lied to get her to like him. Kip puts a bandage over his zit and tells Rebecca that he got in a fight while playing hockey.

Chuck suspects he has gonorrhea and confronts his girlfriend Jane who then confronts her lover/ex-boyfriend Peter, accusing Peter's girlfriend Siska of starting the STD chain. Renzo tries to convince Jim to ask Annie out, but Jim's conversation with Annie's roommate Carla leads him to believe Annie wouldn't date a man in a wheelchair. When Rebecca asks why he got into a fight, Kip confesses that he made it all up.