Mike sustains an injury that threatens his spot in the MLB All-Star Game. Ginny attempts to balance her career and personal life. The Padres are blindsided when Oscar signs a star catcher from Cuba.

Oscar informs Mike that during their game in San Francisco, Duarte will be the catcher. He assures Mike, he is not on his way out. Mike recalls a moment from his past. Amelia tries to find a way to fix Ginny's video.

A rain delay at Petco Park causes the team to hold Kangaroo Court in the clubhouse in order to pass the time. Meanwhile, per Oscar's suggestion, Mike mulls over the option of trading to a new team, and an unexpected visit from Ginny's brother, Will, causes friction with Amelia.

Mike becomes the biggest news story in the MLB when rumors start about him waiving his no-trade clause. Meanwhile, Evelyn and Will go in on a business venture together, but Amelia is concerned that it relies too heavily on Ginny's fame.