Zelda has a dream about Tim the Witch Smeller, a revenge-seeking witch hunter! Later, Tim comes to Greendale and accidently kidnaps Harvey!

Romeo is brought into reality so Zelda can have a prom date and so Sabrina can get a little help from him about love. But when Enchantra makes a surprise visit, hell breaks loose.

Sabrina and Enchantra accidently swap bodies. They realise that each other's lives are stressful but Stabbenback, Enchantras griffin servant, is trying to take over the netherworld!