As a new year begins at Boring High School, Oregon, freshman Luke impresses his friends by inviting sophomore Kate, the principal's daughter, to his house.

Luke plans his next move with Kate, who's having a rough day at school, and discovers VHS tapes that bring back emotional memories.

A pulled fire alarm lands Luke in detention and his mother in Principal Ken's office. The irate drama club plots revenge on the AV kids.

Luke tries to help Kate work through her feelings. Oliver and Luke hold film auditions. Emaline takes Kate shopping. Ken invites Luke over for dinner.

An exasperated Luke scrambles to finish the movie. Kate has important conversations with Emaline and Luke. McQuaid gets a sudden boost of confidence.

The Boring community comes together for the movie premiere, where angst simmers even as wounds heal and relationships blossom.