After a theft at Bayside, a former Douglas student becomes a suspect. Meanwhile, Mac and Jamie fall for the same girl and compete with each other to win her attention.

DeVante faces consequences after a student says he pushed him. Mac becomes a payphone.

Lexi and Mac attempt to break up Jordan and Aisha's new relationship. Daisy tries to go wild.

Zack, Kelly, Jessie and Slater reunite at the Homecoming Gala, but can't find the same spark they used to have. They all discover that Principal Toddman has a secret. Meanwhile, Daisy and Lexi fundraise together and Mac desperately tries to come up with a perfect Homecoming prank.

Aisha tries out for the wrestling team. Daisy has a crush on Gil, the new student council VP.