When two Vermont teens are kidnapped on their way home from a basketball game, the team is led to a wayward pastor and his brother. Also, Remy attends a hearing for his brother's murderer.

When a news anchor is shot dead in the station's parking lot, the task force must dive into a story she was working on to track down her killer; Remy debates revisiting the case around his brother's murder.

The witness Remy and Kristen are visiting in prison is put in danger when a riot breaks out, leaving the staff and visitors held hostage by two murderous gangs.

The team helps Remy try to catch his brother’s real killer 25 years after Mikey was murdered.