Diskuse o Interstellar

I think Interstellar was a very interesting movie, and I enjoyed it a lot. But there a two things I find damn stupid and really poorly executed in the story telling and so I must blame Nolan for that foolishness.

1: when he returns to a better future and now an old Murph, they pretty much show no true interest and her new family seem to just brush him off. I know, I know the movie sort of just explain this that she wanted to see him before she would die.. but I found that whole thing utterly poorly executed in the storytelling. Not least because the whole damn movie was about him coming back home to her... talk about an anticlimax

2: he went into the black hole and communicated back in time to her via some alien gizmo .... holishit wait what???? And no one care one bit what the hell happened. Yes again I know Murph said no one believed her when she talked about a ticking clock telling her the secrets of the universe... (did she really try to say that to her NASA peps)... but even Murph cared not at all how the hell he did it... truly this was the most mind blowingly fantastic thing about his whole tale... unbelievable miss in the storytelling .... and sooo easy to fix.

3: also, what about his son and his family line?

4: and then for some reason he goes to rekindle with Brand, because ... sure they love each other now... what, when was this ever shown during their travels? In fact, it was made clear Brand was in love with one of the stranded explorers whom she was believed to end up with... but ind the end, now Cooper was her love interest..... yes I know again that the movie showed us her love was dead and buried on that planet... but Cooper did not know this. Confusing.

5: why not send supplies to Brand first btw, I mean this better future seem to be pretty resourceful... but he just take off.

Okay, I said two things .. but still the movie could be brilliant and then just falls apart in this final act. In ways that could so easily have been fixed.

Am I wrong ?

5 odpovědí (na stránce 1 z 1)

Jump to last post

1, 2 & 3 = yes.

4 is also a yes. He could have deserted all his relatives on a whim only to end his days playing gooseberry on some far flung planet. This really is riddled with guff; emotionally, scientifically, logically and (if it is a word) narratively.

A real shame as it had a great atmosphere and elements I enjoyed.

6/10

The movie is fine just as it is.

YESSS

I can't remember much about this movie except that I was initially impressed but then meh. Like you said, it was very anticlimactic. To me Nolan's storytelling was as if he were trying to mix 2001-ish intelligence with a Star Wars-ian everyman plot. Oil & water, dude pick one or the other because they don't mix.

Very "flowing" for a while until the big wave planet scene. Too much confusing and forced. Not a masterpiece.

Pretty pity because with little adjustments could have been that kind of movie you enjoy rewatch yearly or every 2 years but the second half of the movie doesn't deserve so much energy and appreciation from me

Nemůžete nalézt film nebo seriál? Přihlaste se pro jeho vytvoření.

Globální

s zaměřit panel hledání
p otevřít nabídku profilu
esc zavřít otevřené okno
? otevřít okno klávesových zkratek

Na stránkách médií

b zpět (nebo na nadřazený záznam, pokud to jde)
e na stránku úprav

Na stránkách sezón

(šipka vpravo) na další sezónu
(šipka vlevo) na předchozí sezónu

Na stránkách epizod

(šipka vpravo) na další epizodu
(šipka vlevo) na předchozí epizodu

Na všech stránkách obrázků

a otevřít okno přidání obrázku

Na všech stránkách úprav

t otevřít výběr překladu
ctrl+ s odeslat formulář

Na stránkách diskusí

n vytvořit novou diskusi
w přepnout stav zhlédnutí
p přepnout veřejný a soukromý
c přepnout zavřít a otevřít
a otevřít aktivitu
r odpovědět na diskusi
l na poslední odpověď
ctrl+ enter odeslat zprávu
(šipka vpravo) další stránka
(šipka vlevo) předchozí stránka

Nastavení

Want to rate or add this item to a list?

Přihlásit se