Cast 36

1. 

   Tony Goldwyn

   Joshua

2. 

   F. Murray Abraham

   Father Tardone

3. 

   Kurt Fuller

   Father Pat Hayes

4. 

   Stacy Edwards

   Maggie

5. 

   Giancarlo Giannini

   The Pope

6. Eddie Bo Smith Jr.

   Theo

7. Michael Guido

   Aaron

8. Matt Zeigler

   Kevin

9. 

   Colleen Camp

   Joan Casey

10. 

    Marc Grapey

    Steve Casey (as Mark Grapey)

11. Rich Komenich

    Ray Persini

12. Dale Calandra

    Leo Persini

13. 

    Cedric Young

    Charlie

14. 

    Tim Grimm

    Bishop Anderson

15. Jordan Allen

    Michael Reed

16. James Meeks

    Muntoe

17. Bernie Landis

    Rabbi Szeneth

18. 

    John Sierros

    Policeman (credit only)

19. 

    David Pasquesi

    Eli Cohen

20. Tom Brainard

    Young Pastor

21. Tim Decker

    Reverend Daily

22. 

    Linsey Page Morton

    Paulina

23. 

    Beth Lacke

    Sally

24. Tom Roland

    Cardinal Riccardo

25. 

    Coburn Goss

    Father Delorenzo (as Coby Goss)

26. Jim Carrane

    Father Tumelo

27. Ilio Bruno

    Cardinal Napoli

28. Barrie D. Buckner Jr.

    Henry (as Barrie D. Buckner)

29. Jason Borgardt

    Randall

30. Ken Stimson

    Reverend Williams

31. Bob O'Donnell

    Bishop Representative

32. Tai Anderson

    Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"

33. Brad Avery

    Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"

34. David Carr

    Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"

35. Mark Lee

    Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"

36. 

    Mac Powell

    Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"

Crew 24