After the kiss in the field, Dominic is unsure if he and Luke are already in a relationship. He tries to know if they are going to the grad ball together, but Dominic knows that nothing will be official unless Luke speaks with Karen.

Luke is torn between love and career when Coach Mark warns him that his relationship with Dominic might affect his chances of getting a college basketball scholarship. Unable to reach Luke for days, Dominic grows extremely worried.

The stars have aligned for Dominic when he gets into his dream university and becomes a strong candidate for class valedictorian. To top it all off, Luke publicizes their relationship and attends the graduation ball as his date.

The video of Dominic and Luke kissing at the grad ball goes viral, which places them in a bad situation with their school. Their relationship is soon put to the test when Fr. Giboy, the school headmaster, imposes a punishment for what they did.

Not wanting to disappoint his parents, Dominic breaks up with Luke. As their high school journey comes to an end, he remains steadfast in burying the memories they had, but Luke strives to prove that nothing can defy the love destined by the stars.