80's icon Taylor Dayne tells it to Rick's heart when she gives him first dibs at some memorabilia from her tours. Will she accept the offer or will Taylor say "Don't Rush Me?" Then, Chum hopes the force is strong with him as a seller brings a nutcracker Darth Vader into the shop. And later, Corey tries to hit a high note when a seller comes into the shop with an award given to Dolly Parton and Porter Wagoner.

Rick takes a Bricklin SV-1 out for a test drive. But is this sports car a safe bet, or a bright yellow lemon? Then, a seller makes Chum a whale-y big offer, but does he have the backbone to make the deal? Meanwhile, Corey and Chum try to stay afloat with a limited-edition Nike raft and briefcase. Will he just do it or just don't it? And finally, Rick and Chum make a long-distance song request on a Shyver Multiphone, but will the seller be singing their tune?

When a customer walks into the shop with a camera that shot the first footage of Elvis, will Rick and Corey shake up a good deal, or will they return to sender? Then Chum tries to dig up some info on a mysterious fossil. Is it a dinosaur egg or will Chum end up with egg on his face? Then Rick tries to strike black gold with a Standard Oil stock certificate. Will he buy low and sell high or will the market crash? And finally, Corey chomps his teeth into some Holyfield/Tyson tickets.

When an outfit supposedly worn by Alice Cooper hits the counter, it'll be "No More Mr. Nice Guy" as Rick tries to land a deal. Then, Chum gets mercenary when he makes an offer on a 7-foot tall Deadpool PEZ dispenser. Will the seller accept, or is it all a joke to them? After, Rick and Chum trade looks at sheets of MetaZoo cards with an old adversary--will Rick get burned on a deal again? And later, Rick and Corey go for the gold on a sale of a 1988 Winter Olympics torch. But will they cross the finish line?

A seller comes into the shop with some chef whites signed by the actor who played the iconic Soup Nazi on Seinfeld. Will Rick and Chum say `No deal' for you or will they reach an agreement on price?

When a seller brings an E.T. printer's proof movie poster into the shop, Chum phones his resident expert for advice; Rick and Corey take a Civil War rifle out to the range; Rick investigates a dog shaped diamond.

Chum makes a surreal offer on a Salvador Dalí lithograph of Pablo Picasso; a seller brings in recordings of FDR's Fireside Chats; Rick and Chum test out a Civil War primed revolver; a model of the Death Star hits the counter.

Rick checks out a horde of coins from Kentucky – but is all that glitters gold? Or will Rick be played for a fool? Then, Chum gets into the spirit when a mentalist brings in a magical clock. Will it be time for a deal, or will Chum get ghosted? Later, Corey isn’t ready to say die to a deal when a seller brings in a poster from “The Goonies” – but will this be treasure, or will Corey be cursed? And finally, Chum tries to drum up a deal on a sparkling snare. Will the seller feel the rhythm, or will Chum have to tap out?

A seller brings in a signed Righteous Brothers record; Rick fine-tunes an offer for a 1950's Gretsch guitar; Chum is locked and loaded when he checks out a Palmer rifle from the Civil War.